Menu
Menu

Main navigation

  • Home
  • Find work
    • Find work
    • MAX Connect
    MAX Employment Services
  • Improve your skills
    • Improve your skills
    • Find a course
    • Study with us
    • Learning resources
      • Living in Australia
      • Learning English
      • Using computers
    Training courses
  • Health and disability
    • Health and disability
    • Health assessments
      • Do you need an assessment?
      • Refer someone for a disability assessment
    • Manage your disability at work
    • Group health programs
    • NDIS and Disability Employment Services
    • Long-term disability
    • Therapy Services
    • School leavers and students
    • Injury or Illness
    Support services
  • Help and advice
    • Help and advice
      • Getting started
      • Resumes and cover letters
      • Improve your skills
      • Health and wellbeing
      • Applications and interviews
      • Job searching tools
      • Starting work
      • Ongoing support
    • Frequently asked questions
    • Your rights and privacy
    • Help with Centrelink
    • Useful contacts
    • Feedback and complaints
    Get the support you want
  • Employer services
    • Employer services
    • National partnerships
    • Find candidates
    • How we support employers
      • Financial support
      • Employee Assistance Program
    • Employ someone with disability
      • Benefits of diversity
      • Types of disabilities
    • Offer work experience
      • Join the PaTH program
      • Offer a traineeship
      • Be a work for the dole host
    • Our work with employers
    Find great staff
  • What we do
    • What we do
    • MAX Employment
      • jobactive
      • Disability Employment Services
      • NDIS School Leaver Employment Supports
      • Parents Next
    • MAX Support
      • Adult Migrant English Program
      • Skills for Education and Employment
      • Youth jobs PaTH
      • Vocational Training
      • Child Welfare Assessments
      • Disability Assessments
      • National Panel of Assessors
      • Program for Students with Disability
      • Therapy Services
    • MAX Community
      • Housing Employment Program
      • Opportunity Pathways Program
      • School Based Trainee Program
      • Prison-based services
    Our services and programs
  • About us
    • About us
    • Careers with MAX
    • Our customer promise
    • Our partners
    • MAXIMUS Worldwide
    • Our impact
    • Our leadership team
    • MAX Foundation
    Learn about MAX

Header Navigation Secondary Menu

  • News
  • Careers with MAX
  • Locations
  • Contact
  • Feedback and complaints

Language menu

  • ngôn ngữ tiếng Việt
  • اللغة العربية
  • پښتو ژبه
  • دری
  • 中文 Zhōngwén
  • ਪੰਜਾਬੀ ਭਾਸ਼ਾ
  • हिन्दी भाषा
  • 中文
  • Wikang Filipino
  • زبان فارسي
Aa

MAX Connect

Social Icons

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Youtube

Talk to our team

MAX solutions

MAX Solutions.

X

Services

  • Disability Employment Services
  • Assessments Australia
  • jobactive

Training Courses

  • Adult Migrant English Program
  • Skills for Education and Employment
  • PaTH Employabililty Skills Training

Articles

  • Getting Started
  • Resumes and Cover Letters
  • Health and Wellbeing

General

  • Careers
  • Find an office
  • Feedback and Complaints
  • FAQs
MAXsolutions
  • English
    Choose a language:
    • ngôn ngữ tiếng Việt
    • اللغة العربية
    • پښتو ژبه
    • دری
    • 中文 Zhōngwén
    • ਪੰਜਾਬੀ ਭਾਸ਼ਾ
    • हिन्दी भाषा
    • 中文
    • Wikang Filipino
    • زبان فارسي
  • Aa
  • MAXconnect
Search
Locations Contact

Breadcrumb

Home
  • Home
  • Should you hire an overqualified candidate?
  • Should you hire an overqualified candidate?

    Published by MAXSolutions on May 19 2020
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • Linked in
    Should you hire an overqualified candidate?
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • Linked in

    Should you hire an overqualified candidate?

    The cataclysmic changes in the Australian business landscape during COVID-19 are continuing to reverberate around workplaces across the country.

    Economic downturns always lead to a glut of highly qualified workers entering the race for jobs. This means the age-old question of whether to hire someone who is ‘overqualified’ has just become more important again. 

    If you are in a position to be employing staff, you likely have an immense pool of talent available to you, including overqualified candidates. 

    What is an overqualified candidate/employee?

    A candidate is typically considered overqualified if their level of education is higher and/or their workplace experience is in roles that exceed the one on offer in both pay and hierarchical positioning.

    What that looks like for each role you have on offer, and each candidate that comes your way is going to be different, but generally recruiters get a sense quickly if a candidate is a match for the role, reaching up with little or no qualifications or experience, or indeed overqualified. 

    Why do overqualified people apply?

    The reason why an overqualified candidate is applying typically provides some guidance to employers as to how to proceed.

    Under more normal economic circumstances, overqualified candidates can present themselves for a multitude of reasons – to readjust their work/life balance, to use as a workforce re-entry point, to change industry or careers, to chase an altruistic dream, just to name a few. 

    Each may suggest a perfect fit or be the perfect incentive to pass over a candidate, depending on how your circumstances marry with theirs. 

    Due largely to the restrictions put in place to protect us from COVID-19, the number of Australians employed dropped by nearly 600,000 in April. Many hundreds of thousands more may join that number in the coming months (source: ABC News). 

    Given the vast majority of people on the hunt for jobs right now are likely to be hunting as a result of the drastic economic fallout and these mass job losses, we’ll focus on candidates needing a job as the ‘why’.

    Should you hire an overqualified candidate?

    Of course, there’s no right or wrong answer – we all know hiring is a nuanced business at the best of times.

    The Australian HR Institute wrote in 2017 that “overqualified candidates are equal parts tantalising and terrifying.”

    Here are some things to consider when those overtly impressive resumes pile up on your desk. We’ll start with the terrifying and end with the tantalising. 

    The Terrifying - Why do employers often reject overqualified candidates?

    Generally speaking employers are wary of hiring overqualified candidates and are quick to reject overqualified candidate applications at the outset.
    Thought processes and reasoning might include:

    “They won’t last long”

    Concerns the candidate will move on as soon as a better position becomes available. This may be on to a job with better pay, more suited to the employee’s skillset or with more opportunity for career progression. A quick turnover means the costs and time associated with onboarding are wasted and the recruitment process must begin again – employers are understandably often unwilling to take this risk.

    “They’ll get bored”

    Concerns that overqualified candidates will become bored and dissatisfied are common. Some of the flow on effects of boredom might include:

    • The employee asking for more money in order to make up for the lack of stimulation
    • The employee asking for a promotion in order to gain job satisfaction 
    • The employee becoming complacent and approaching the job with little initiative or scraping through to complete the bare minimum in a day
    • The employee quitting or moving on. 

    “They’ll want to make lots of changes”

    Concerns the employee will approach the job overzealously, looking to make improvements in processes and practices at every turn. 
    Managers have every right to look for employees that will fit their team, and while some initiative and suggestions for improvements in efficiency are welcome, constant requests to change in the name of improvement can be seen as incredibly destabilising for a manager, other team members and existing processes and practices. 

    “They’ll upset the team dynamics”

    Concerns that the candidate, by their very overqualification, will disrupt interpersonal dynamics and threaten the stability of the team. 
    This can particularly be an issue if a recruit inadvertently reverts to a more managerial tone in word or deed with other team members. This can cause great dissatisfaction among your existing team base.

    Further, if we’re being honest, many managers are very reluctant to hire someone who is similarly qualified as themselves if they might feel threatened and insecure in their own position.

    “They’re taking a job from someone who really needs it”

    Concerns that giving a job to someone overqualified is robbing the opportunity from someone who needs it more. 
    Many view those with education and experience as the lucky ones, and those without as people needing a helping hand to get on their feet and get going in their career. Managers might be keen to give an opportunity to the latter, rather than hiring someone who is in a more ‘privileged’ position. 

     

    The Tantalising - What are the positives of hiring overqualified candidates?

    This is all sounding rather grim—so what are the positives of hiring overqualified candidates? Some general tantalising thoughts might be:

    “They are quicker to train and need less supervision”

    An opportunity for quicker onboarding. For the most part, people with an enhanced skillset and years of experience across organisations and roles bring know-how and practical understanding of how things work. 

    Typically, this translates into speedier onboarding and less training required to hit the ground running. It may particularly help you out of a tight spot if you’re hiring in a hurry.

    Further, more competent staff often require less supervision and management time ongoing. This helps managers to concentrate on other areas of work that can maximise efficiencies and even concentrate on important projects that continually get pushed aside in order to attend to the urgent. 
    If the employee was to leave shortly after beginning, this loss may be offset by the quicker training time and the progress they may help you make in a shorter period (see below). Your return on investment may just surprise you. 

    “They will bring fresh ideas and experience”

    An opportunity to inject fresh ideas and make positive changes. Employees who bring a wide range of experiences and skills often offer fresh and innovative ideas. What was considered a concern or a negative above, can of course also be viewed as a positive.

    New eyes cast over your processes that see through the lens of previous experiences can bring you efficiencies, processes that better satisfy your customer base, ideas that keep your team safer … the list goes on.

    Again, even if your overqualified employee leaves after a short time, the cost of recruiting may be offset in the short or medium future by the various business gains they helped you make.

    “They could step up and accomplish more in the role”

    An opportunity to grow the expectation of the position. Have you ever wished your staff would step up and get more done? While an overqualified person might get bored and go on autopilot achieving just the bare minimum, if you choose well, they may just set a higher bar in the role.

    Not only will they be accomplishing more for you, if you have other team members in the same role, they may be inspired to achieve more each day. 

    Furthermore, if you have the tenacity, you could develop a mentoring program to allow your (once trained) recruit to mentor other team members. Even though they may be on the same pay grade, a mentoring program could allow your overqualified employee to gain some great job satisfaction (reducing the chance of losing them), while at the same time helping to lift up your other team members.

    “They could make me look good!”

    An opportunity to help a manager look good. Managers that are secure in their own talent and skillset will be quick to hire the most qualified and experienced person for the role – assuming they will be a good fit for the team and its culture. 

    An employee that gives more than is expected, helps bring innovative changes and efficiencies and ultimately improves the bottom line is the type of employee that helps a team produce beyond expectations. Good talent that translates into quality contributions helps both the business and the manager themselves look good. 

    Good managers hire the best workers they can afford. They aren't afraid of workers who might be older, smarter, or more experienced. They manage the skills of their employees to help the team produce at its best level. That's what gets managers promoted ~ The Balance Careers

     

    Other things to consider when considering hiring an overqualified candidate

    Make sure the job isn’t too menial

    Being overqualified is one thing but hiring a former Chief Operating Officer to do data entry is a recipe for failure.
    While some overqualification can be ideal (for the reasons outlined above), an excessive gap between the required skills and the skills on offer is far from ideal.

    Are they bringing useful skills to the table?

    Are the skills and experience they are bringing to the table be useful to you? Are those skills worth the risks outlined in the ‘terrifying’ list above?

    Are they the right fit for the team?

    This is obviously a must check item for every hiring prospect, but there’s an added layer of complexity when it comes to hiring someone you may ask to mentor other team members, or who might be the one delivering ideas for change in team meetings.

    Consider from the outset if their manner would give this scenario the best chance of success or not. 

    Communication during the hiring process

    Although for the purposes of this article we are assuming the candidate is overqualified due to the COVID-19 economic fallout and that their ‘why’ is needing a job, it’s important to communicate during the recruitment process. Things to consider discussing with your potential candidate include:

    • How long they envisage staying in the role.
    • What other things you might be able to offer them (eg. Flexibility in working hours, bonuses for introducing efficiencies, a mentoring role) to inspire and fulfil them.
    • Whether they see themselves staying in the organisation if they’re able to move up the corporate ladder. If you don’t see opportunities for them to do this, be up front at the beginning. They may walk away if they understand the risk they are taking and you can save both of you the trouble.
    • Examples of when they have brought about change in previous roles, and how they have coordinated the change process. Do their examples give you confidence that they could help bring about change in a reasonable way without ruffling too many feathers?
    • Whether they have experience in mentoring and whether they feel they have what it takes to mentor others.

    One parting thought…

    If your candidate is looking like a great fit for many reasons, but has been honest with you that they may not stick around forever, would you consider offering them a contract?

    A contract of six months for example, might give them the financial stability they’re looking for while they weather the economic storm and wait for something more suited to their career trajectory to come along. At the same time, you can view them as the most qualified worker you can afford and look to get the most out of them for you during the agreed upon time.

    Lateral thinking like this may give you both an excellent rainbow during the COVID storm. 

     

    The MAX difference

    At MAX we’re about giving every person, every chance. As more people join us in their quest to find employment in the fallout of the COVID-19 pandemic, we’re committed to supporting our customers into work and partnering with employers secure them the best possible candidates for their business.

    If you would like to talk to us about your recruitment needs, contact our team on 1800 603 503. 
     

    Tags
    • Advice
    • Employer
    • Log in or register to post comments
    Category
    Case studies

    Most popular help and advice

    5 ways to sell yourself in a job interview

    5 ways to sell yourself in a job interview

    Published by MAXSolutions on April 27 2020
     

    Dealing with online application forms

    Dealing with online application forms

    Published by MAXSolutions on October 9 2018
     

    Following up your application

    Following up your application

    Published by MAXSolutions on October 9 2018
     

    Tips to get an interview from cold calling.

    Tips to get an interview from cold calling.

    Published by MAXSolutions on December 7 2020
     
    More articles
    Was this article useful?
    Why did you choose Yes?
    Why did you choose No?

    Contact us

    • Have a question?

      Chat Now

      Find quick answers about employment services.

    • Customer Enquiries

      1800 603 503

      If you are a new or existing customer or have an enquiry about a service, contact our Customer Servicing Team

    • Need support?

      1800 807 505

      Talk to someone in our health team.

        

      If you need urgent help or are in an emergency, please dial 000.

      Alternatively please call:

      Lifeline: 13 11 14

      Beyond Blue: 1300 224 636

      Respect Domestic Family Violence Service: 1800 737 732

       

    Send us an email:

    • General enquiry
    • Register for Disability Employment Services
    • Register for a service
    • Feedback and complaints

    General Enquiry

    General Enquiry

    Published by MAXSolutions on July 19 2018

    Register for a service

    Register for a service

    Published by MAXSolutions on July 19 2018

    Register with us now

    Register with us now

    Published by MAXSolutions on July 19 2018

    Feedback and complaints

    Feedback and complaints

    Published by MAXSolutions on July 19 2018

    Please fill in the contact form below or   Complete a survey

    Recent posts

    Gympie locals Eat at Candy's
    Where are the employment opportunities in Australia 2020
    4 ways to support employees with disabilities working from home
    The benefits of hiring people with disability
    Celebrate similarity to promote diversity

    Monthly archive

    • July 2020
    • June 2020
    • May 2020
    • April 2020
    • January 2020
    • December 2019
    • November 2019
    • May 2019
    • April 2019
    • October 2018
    • June 2018

    Most popular help and advice

    5 ways to sell yourself in a job interview

    5 ways to sell yourself in a job interview

    Published by MAXSolutions on April 27 2020
     

    Dealing with online application forms

    Dealing with online application forms

    Published by MAXSolutions on October 9 2018
     

    Following up your application

    Following up your application

    Published by MAXSolutions on October 9 2018
     

    Tips to get an interview from cold calling.

    Tips to get an interview from cold calling.

    Published by MAXSolutions on December 7 2020
     
    More articles
    • Find a MAX office near you

      Office

      Our locations

       
    • Register with us

      Edit

      Register now

       
    • Talk to someone now

      Call

      Contact us

       
    • Let us know how we're doing

      Feedback

      Feedback

       
    Providing employment, disability and training services

    Providing employment, disability and training services in suburban and regional areas across Australia including Brisbane, Sydney, Melbourne, Darwin, Adelaide, Hobart, Perth, Canberra.

    Providing employment, disability and training services

    Ensuring your safety and support

    If you need help or support, our offices are a safe environment.

    Contact us

    Language menu

    • ngôn ngữ tiếng Việt
    • اللغة العربية
    • پښتو ژبه
    • دری
    • 中文 Zhōngwén
    • ਪੰਜਾਬੀ ਭਾਸ਼ਾ
    • हिन्दी भाषा
    • 中文
    • Wikang Filipino
    • زبان فارسي

    Footer

    • Home
    • Privacy
    • Terms of use
    • Quality
    • Contact
    • Locations
    • Sitemap
    • MAXConnect

    Social Icons

    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Youtube

    © Copyright 2019 MAX Solutions. All rights reserved Registered Training Organisation: 0667

    Ask a question